New York Times Book Reviews Include a Self-Published Title

According to a blog post from Indie Reader, great news has struck the self-publishing community: the New York Times has reviewed a self-published title in its prestigious book review section. While the Times has been reviewing and ranking ebooks for a short time, this marks the first time an author–albeit an author with a strong platform due to his well-known body of work as an entertainment critic, as opposed to an unknown debut author–has crossed over into its mainstream book reviews with a two-page review.

The Revolution Was Televised by Alan Sepinwall, television critic for HitFix with his own widely popular blog-column, “What’s Alan Watching?” details how different television programs have changed the crime drama genre forever.

The interesting aspect of the Times‘ review is that it isn’t mentioned until late in the piece that Sepinwall’s book is self-published, a fact that once would have been noted in the headline. What does this mean for a greater acceptance and a “we’ve finally brought down the barriers to publishing” mentality behind self-publishing? According to Amy Edelman, president of Indie Reader and the writer of a blog post about the Times‘ review, it won’t mean much for now.

“Does this mean that The Times will start reviewing other indie titles?  Doubtful.  In her piece in Forbes announcing the news, Suw Charman-Anderson states that ‘Most reviewers don’t want to deal with self-published authors directly because they don’t really want to deal with any authors directly…’ (emphasis Edelman’s)…and that ‘reviewers depend on publishers acting as winnowers, sorting out the wheat from the chaff, and at least attempting to make sure that they are sent books they are actually interested in.’  All true.”

What might actually signify the end of the stigma is if a prestigious and iconic outlet reviews a book and fails to mention whether it is self-published or traditionally done. That is when the attitudes about self-publishing will have truly died away, and a book can simply be appreciated on its merits instead of its route to publication.

Mercy Pilkington (1082 Posts)

Mercy Pilkington is a young-adult author and a teacher in a correctional facility. She does not have a single textbook in her classroom. With the top-of-the-line technology at her disposal and the low reading ability of many of her students, there’s no need for standard paper texts. Instead she relies on e-readers, iPads, desktop PCs, Polycom video conferencing equipment for virtual field trips, live streaming for science demonstrations, and text-to-speech read-aloud software to teach English and science. Within the next ten years, public school classrooms across the country are going to look a lot more like Mercy’s classroom because the educational possibilities with these kinds of technologies are limitless. Have a question? Send an email to mercypilkington@yahoo.com

Related posts:

1. New York Times to debut ebook Bestseller list for 2011
2. New York Times Agrees to Apple Terms, Offering In-App Subscriptions for the iPad
3. IndieReader Helps Connect Authors with Their Readers
4. ForeWord Reviews Announces Book of the Year Competition
5. Smashwords Contributes Four Authors to the New York Times Bestseller List
6. Flaws in Online Book Reviews